|
INDICE
|
|
|
The results of a typical XRF scan are
shown in Figure 1, where the spectrum for sample C2 is reproduced.
The results show that this bell, from the Department of Nariño,
8th-13th century AD, is made in a relatively pure copper containing
some arsenic. The discovery of arsenical copper alloys from the
Nariño area is not so surprising, since the Department of Nariño
is contiguous with the Ecuadorian border, representing the
Southerly limit of the smelting of copper from arsenical ores, as
we understand the data today. Nonetheless, it is interesting that
arsenical copper should be found from the Nariño area and suggests
the possibility that the bell is an import into the region from the
Ecuadorian territory. The archaeological area of Nariño, in any
case, extends into the Ecuadorian highlands. which makes the
possibility for trade that much more possible. Tin bronze beads
from the Nariño area nave also been reported (Scott 1980) and as
more detailed analyses become available, it is very likely that
further examples of either arsenical copper or tin bronze will be
reported from the Nariño area.
X-ray fluorescence analysis is
extremely useful, since the objects can be examined totally
non-destructively, but it is inadequate for reporting on the range
of trace elements needed to characterize copper objects in order to
decide whether they represent smelted copper or not. If major
alloying elements such as arsenic, antimony, or tin are absent,
what evidence is required of elemental composition in order to make
an informed judgement? In the present study, the ICP-MS technique
was employed to examine elemental composition over a range of 65
elements which, can be conveniently measured by ICP-MS to the low
parts per million simultaneously. Special analytical techniques
were applied additionally, to estimate low levels of arsenic, and
some elements nave been quantitatively determined where they are of
especial significance, such as: antimony, arsenic, cobalt, iron,
nickel, silver, tin and zinc. The ICP-MS instrumentation has made
very significant progress ayer the last ten years in terms of
resolution, interferences, and detection limits for samples of 10mg
- 30mg in weight. For the analyses, about 15mg of clean metal
drillings were removed with a high speed tungsten steel twist
drill.
It has become increasingly necessary
to specify the full range of elements which were sought in such a
detailed analysis, since, in future years, we mar Jet discover new
patterns in the data and new significance to the presence or
absence of a particular element: this is why the results presented
here are shown for all 65 elements sought in the study: it is
particularly relevant to the problem of distinguishing between
native and smelted copper in ancient Colombia, since very few
objects made in ancient Colombia do not contain gold and silver,
even if present only in the parts per million, since contamination
with gold on melting and casting would be highly probable; gold
being a universal commodity in Colombia as far as the metalsmiths
are concerned. The occurrence of elevated trace amounts of gold and
silver in the copper alloys hinders any possible inferences
concerning copper sources based on these two elements. It is also
common for native gold in Colombia to be contaminated with small
amounts of copper from melting without the alloy necessarily being
a deliberate tumbaga alloy, although this kind of alloy is also
difficult to characterize since native gold, besides silver may
also contain copper, although this is usually less than 1 %.
|